Small Town Hearts

The Teacher of Pine Hollow · Chapter 2 of 6

Chapter 2

By My Life Story Editorial · Published · Updated

By dawn, the blizzard had weakened from a roar to a restless wind.

Cade had slept perhaps an hour.

Eleanor had slept in fragments.

Every time she woke, she saw him doing something.

Feeding the fire.

Checking the windows.

Heating water.

Looking outside.

Once she opened her eyes and found him sitting at the table, carving a small piece of maple by lantern light.

His hands fascinated her.

People in Pine Hollow spoke about Cade’s hands as if they were weapons.

Hands that could break a man’s ribs.

Hands that could lift a wagon tongue alone.

Hands that once dragged a frightened horse from a flooded creek.

But Eleanor watched those same fingers guide a knife through maple with movements so delicate the blade seemed to be drawing rather than cutting.

“What are you making?” she asked.

Cade looked up.

“Didn’t mean to wake you.”

“You didn’t.”

He hesitated before turning the carving toward her.

A little owl was beginning to emerge from the wood.

“For one of the schoolchildren?”

“Maybe.”

“You make toys for them?”

“Sometimes.”

“I’ve wondered where some of those came from.”

Cade looked almost embarrassed.

Several Pine Hollow children possessed wooden animals their parents claimed had simply “appeared” on porches.

Eleanor smiled.

“The mountain ghost leaves presents.”

“Don’t tell anybody.”

“Your reputation would be ruined.”

That earned a quiet laugh.

It was the first time Eleanor had heard it.

Cade’s laughter surprised her. It was deep but strangely shy, like something seldom used.

By seven, he had prepared the sled.

Eleanor protested when she saw it.

“You intend to pull me?”

“And supplies.”

“That is absurd.”

“Why?”

“Because you are not a draft horse.”

Cade looked at the harness.

Then at her.

“I’m bigger than one.”

Eleanor tried not to laugh and failed.

They left shortly after sunrise.

The forest had become a white kingdom.

Branches bent under snow.

The sky was pale.

Cade moved steadily, pulling the sled while Eleanor sat beneath blankets with her injured ankle elevated.

She gave directions when she recognized landmarks.

Three hours later, smoke appeared.

The Collins farm.

Martha Collins ran from the house.

“Eleanor!”

Behind her came Jacob Collins.

His relief vanished when he saw Cade.

For one second he stared at the giant as if a bear had walked onto his property.

Then he saw Eleanor.

“What happened?”

“Storm caught me.”

“She’s hurt,” Cade said.

Jacob nodded nervously.

“Bring her in.”

Cade lifted Eleanor from the sled.

Inside, eleven-year-old Samuel Collins lay beneath quilts, face flushed and breathing fast.

Eleanor forgot her pain.

“Put me beside him.”

Cade lowered her into a chair.

She examined Samuel.

His pulse was rapid.

His lungs sounded congested.

But he was still responsive.

“He needs fluids. Cool cloths. Keep the room warm, not hot.”

For six hours, Eleanor worked.

Cade became her hands and legs.

She told him what to fetch.

He fetched it.

She asked for water.

He heated it.

She needed Samuel lifted.

Cade held the child with such care that Martha stared.

By afternoon, the boy’s fever began to break.

Martha cried openly.

“He’s going to live?”

“I think so,” Eleanor said.

Jacob Collins looked toward Cade.

“I suppose we owe you.”

Cade shook his head.

“You owe her.”

Eleanor immediately corrected him.

“No. Samuel would have lost precious hours if Cade had not found me.”

Jacob cleared his throat.

“Well.”

The farmer was not a cruel man, but like many in Pine Hollow, he had inherited prejudices without ever examining them.

He extended his hand.

“Thank you, Thornwood.”

Cade looked at it.

Then shook.

Something small changed in that farmhouse.

Not enough.

But something.

Two days later, Cade brought Eleanor home.

By then news had traveled through Pine Hollow.

The teacher had been lost in the blizzard.

Cade Thornwood had found her.

She had spent a night in his cabin.

The first two facts impressed people.

The third interested them far more.

Eleanor discovered this within ten minutes of arriving in town.

Mrs. Abigail Prentice stood outside the mercantile pretending to examine apples while watching Cade carry Eleanor toward her house.

“Good heavens,” Abigail said loudly. “You stayed there all night?”

Eleanor’s shoulders stiffened.

“Yes.”

“Alone?”

Cade stopped walking.

Eleanor felt the muscles in his arms tighten.

She answered calmly.

“No, Mrs. Prentice. We were accompanied by frostbite, a sprained ankle, and the possibility of death. It was crowded.”

A young clerk coughed to hide a laugh.

Abigail reddened.

“I only meant—”

“I know what you meant.”

Cade continued walking.

At Eleanor’s cottage, he set her carefully into a chair.

“You didn’t have to say anything,” he murmured.

“I did.”

“People talk.”

“They always have.”

“About me more than most.”

Eleanor looked at him.

“Does that mean they are entitled to?”

Cade had no answer.

For the next three weeks, he visited every morning.

At first he claimed it was because of her ankle.

He brought wood.

Repaired a loose shutter.

Carried water.

Then the ankle improved.

He continued coming.

Sometimes Eleanor made coffee.

Sometimes he sat near the window and carved while she marked student papers.

Their conversations began cautiously.

Then grew.

She told him about Boston.

About William.

About how grief changed when people became impatient with it.

He told her about Ruby.

About being ten years old and understanding that his father had chosen absence.

One evening, Cade stared into the fire.

“I kept thinking if I worked hard enough, got strong enough, became useful enough, maybe someday he’d hear about me and regret leaving.”

Eleanor lowered the paper in her hand.

“Did he?”

“Don’t know.”

“Do you still care?”

Cade considered that.

“Less than I used to.”

“That sounds healthier than claiming you don’t care at all.”

He looked at her with surprise.

Most people expected men to pretend wounds did not hurt.

Eleanor seemed to expect honesty.

“What about you?” he asked.

“What about me?”

“William’s family.”

Her mouth tightened.

“They believed I should have done more.”

“You were his wife, not God.”

“That distinction escaped them.”

“Do you believe them?”

Eleanor looked into the fire.

“Some days.”

Cade leaned forward.

“You stayed beside him?”

“Every night.”

“You spent everything you had trying to help him?”

“Yes.”

“Then they were wrong.”

The certainty in his voice struck her.

She swallowed.

“Thank you.”

Winter settled over Pine Hollow.

Eleanor returned to teaching with a cane.

One morning, she found a carved owl on her desk.

The children crowded around it.

“Who made it, Miss Ashford?”

Eleanor looked through the window.

Far across the road, Cade was loading lumber onto a wagon.

“I believe,” she said, “a ghost did.”

By Christmas, everyone noticed that Cade Thornwood attended church more often.

He always sat in the final pew because ordinary benches were uncomfortable.

People also noticed Eleanor sometimes walked out afterward beside him.

Then came the gossip.

At first it was teasing.

“Teacher finally tame the giant?”

“Thornwood courting books now?”

Cade ignored it.

Eleanor did too.

But January brought uglier words.

At the general store, three men stood near the stove while Cade purchased flour.

Silas Wade, a sawmill worker with more confidence than wisdom, watched him.

“Heard you’ve been sniffing around the schoolteacher.”

Cade placed coins on the counter.

The storekeeper became very interested in arranging jars.

“Miss Ashford is my friend.”

Silas grinned.

“Friend.”

Cade turned.

“Something funny?”

“Just wondering what a woman her age wants with a man like you.”

Another man chuckled.

Cade’s face hardened.

Silas continued.

“Maybe she wants children.”

That drew laughter.

“Can you imagine that?” someone said. “Old schoolteacher trying to breed with the mountain giant?”

Cade stared at them.

The idea seemed so absurd—Eleanor, forty-three, widowed, dignified Eleanor; himself, the man whose own father rejected him at birth—that he gave one disbelieving laugh.

Not cruel.

Not mocking her.

More like laughing at fate.

Silas misunderstood.

“Exactly!”

Cade’s smile disappeared.

“I wasn’t laughing at her.”

Silas shrugged.

“Still. A child between you two might come out ten feet tall.”

The room went silent.

Cade stepped closer.

Silas backed into the stove.

Cade did not raise a fist.

He did not threaten.

He simply said, “You speak about Mrs. Ashford like that again, you’ll apologize to her.”

“What if I don’t?”

“Then you’ll learn how patient I can be while waiting for you to develop manners.”

Cade collected his flour and left.

Unfortunately, Pine Hollow heard only part of the story.

By afternoon, the version reaching Eleanor was different.

Cade Thornwood had laughed when someone suggested he could have children with her.

She told herself it did not matter.

They were friends.

Nothing more.

Yet that evening, when Cade arrived carrying firewood, Eleanor was colder than the January air.

“You needn’t keep coming.”

He stopped.

“What happened?”

“My ankle is healed.”

“I know.”

“Then your obligation is finished.”

“Obligation?”

“Yes.”

His confusion was genuine.

Eleanor hated that she cared.

“Did you laugh?”

His face changed.

“Who told you?”

“So you did.”

“Eleanor—”

“You found the thought amusing?”

“No.”

“You laughed.”

“Yes, but not because—”

She turned away.

Cade set the wood down.

“I laughed because the idea of me having a family sounds like something from somebody else’s life.”

She looked at him.

“That is not what people said.”

“People say a great many things about me.”

“Why should this be different?”

“Because you know me.”

The words landed between them.

Eleanor’s anger weakened.

Cade took a breath.

“My father looked at me when I was born and decided I was something wrong. I spent half my life thinking maybe he was right. So when somebody said I might have a child someday, I laughed because I’ve never let myself believe anyone would want that with me.”

Eleanor said nothing.

“And when they made a joke about you,” he continued, “I stopped laughing.”

Her eyes softened.

“I didn’t know.”

“I should’ve told you.”

“No. I should have asked before believing gossip.”

Cade looked down.

“We’re both poor at this.”

“At what?”

He met her eyes.

“Whatever this is.”

The room suddenly felt very small.

Eleanor’s pulse quickened.

“Cade.”

He moved one step closer.

“If you tell me to leave, I will.”

She did not.

“I’m twelve years older than you.”

“I can count.”

A startled laugh escaped her.

“I cannot promise you children.”

“I never asked for them.”

“My reputation—”

“Is better than mine.”

“You live alone on a mountain.”

“I could change that.”

Eleanor’s breath caught.

He was not proposing.

Not yet.

But something had shifted.

Cade reached slowly for her hand, giving her every opportunity to move away.

She did not.

His palm swallowed hers.

“I don’t want Pine Hollow deciding what this is before we do,” he said.

“Neither do I.”

“So what do we do?”

Eleanor looked up at the man everyone called a ghost.

“We begin with supper.”

“Supper?”

“Tomorrow evening. Here.”

Cade smiled.

“That sounds dangerous.”

“Terribly.”

The next night he arrived in a clean shirt with his beard trimmed and a bouquet of winterberry branches because no flowers grew in January.

Eleanor put them in a pitcher.

They ate stew.

They talked until midnight.

And when Cade finally stood to leave, he paused at the door.

“Eleanor?”

“Yes?”

“May I kiss you?”

At forty-three, after fifteen years of widowhood, Eleanor Ashford felt herself blush like a girl.

“Yes.”

Cade bent carefully.

The kiss was brief.

Gentle.

Almost reverent.

When he pulled away, neither spoke.

Outside, winter covered the mountains.

Inside, something long frozen began to thaw.

And over the next few months, Pine Hollow would learn that the mountain ghost had not been incapable of love.

He had simply been waiting for someone who did not fear the size of his heart.

✦
YOUR CHOICE

Cookie preferences

Read and listen either way. You can change your choice at any time using the link in the footer.

Essential & reading preferences

Remember this choice and the bookmarks, text size and listening settings you choose. Also supports security and publisher sign-in.

Always available

Help us understand story visits, chapter progress and listening using a random browser identifier. No advertising trackers are enabled.

Your choice lasts 180 days on this browser and this website. Read our privacy policy.